It's now clear that Hollywood made a hot mess of The pornogrpahic eroticism definitionCircle. The Emma Watson-Tom Hanks thriller is currently languishing at 17% fresh on Rotten Tomatoes; worse, it managed an embarrassing 3rd place ranking in its opening weekend box office.
Given that astounding vote of no confidence, you might be tempted to skip the Dave Eggers novel of the same name (on which the movie is based) if you haven't read it already.
That, however, would be a mistake. A better conclusion: skip the movie, pick up the novel, and remember that there are some books that should just never be filmed.
SEE ALSO: Emma Watson's 'The Circle' is so busy railing against technology, it forgets to be a movieEggers' version of the tale, published in 2013, is a different beast altogether. The movie is trying, in its own confused way, to be a dark dystopian thriller; the book is still dark, but it's more of a whimsical satire.
Nothing in The Circle(the book) is designed to hold up to a second of actual scrutiny. It's a deliberate exaggeration, the literary equivalent of fake news. Exactly like a nightmare, it has weird aspects that sound nonsensical as soon as you try to describe them to somebody else. But boy, was it scary when you were in it.
'The Circle' is a deliberate exaggeration, the literary equivalent of fake news
Mae, the Emma Watson character, is deliberately two-dimensional on the page. She's a corporate archetype you may know too well: the naive, eager up-and-comer who drinks the company Kool-Aid and quickly becomes more of a terror than her bosses. We stay with her from her first orientation in the Customer Experience department until the last vestiges of her humanity drip away.
In the movie -- spoiler alert for anyone still planning to see it -- Mae suddenly sees the light and screws the company over in the service of humanity and happy endings. In the book, however, there's no such redemption.
The company of the title isn't supposed to be Google or Facebook; if anything, it's every Silicon Valley company smooshed into one. Eggers didn't do research by visiting their campuses or using their products. He was aiming to represent a mood, not a moment.
That anxious mood isn't just about technology or social media. It's also about extreme notions of transparency that seem like a good idea, but go too far and threaten to upend democracy itself -- hello, Wikileaks.
More than that, it's about how our work life has slowly bled into our home life; how our 9-5 steadily became an 8-7 or a 7-10. How everyone's super nice to each other and the office amenities are amazing, but the sheer number of your duties -- official and "voluntary" -- ramp up to the point where you don't know whether to laugh or cry.
In Eggers' bleak mirror, the 21st century workplace is a machine for creating Attention Deficit Disorder.
SEE ALSO: The moment in 'The Circle' when Emma Watson has a horrifying, dangerous ideaThese are my favorite parts of the book, the ones where Mae is required to write an insane number of tweets (called "zings" in the book) after hours, to chase likes and comments, and to increase her intra-company engagement by attending literally dozens of work events on evenings and weekends.
Given this kind of exaggeration, no one could confuse the world of the book with reality, and yet we all recognize it.
For example, Mae starts the book with two screens, each carrying multiple windows of always-on information about The Circle and the world outside. The number of screens in her cubicle slowly ramps up; by the end of the book, she's manning nine screens.
If you tried to film that it would look absurd, like a Monty Python sketch. The filmmakers opted not to do so, to play up the thriller aspects of the plot instead.
But maybe if they'd opted to make this more of a dark comedy, Black Mirrorstyle, the resulting movie would be riding high at the box office today. Memo to Hollywood: stop dumbing dystopia down.
Oh yes, and even the book's logo was better:
This Tweet is currently unavailable. It might be loading or has been removed.
Topics Books
Everything Writes Itself: An Interview with Black Thought by David MaThe Momentum of Living: An Interview with Clare Sestanovich by Elinor HittClimbing Desolation Peak by Alison BechdelNew York’s Hyphenated History by Pardis MahdaviPlace Determines Who We Are by Julian Brave NoiseCatRedux: Mother for Whom the Whole Sky by The Paris ReviewHistory Is the Throbbing Pulse: An Interview with Doireann Ní Ghríofa by Rhian SasseenAt Home among the Birds: An Interview with Jonathan Meiburg by John Jeremiah SullivanWorldbending by Akwaeke EmeziDiving into the Text by Emilio FraiaAnnouncing Our Summer Subscription Deal by The Paris ReviewRedux: Seventy Memories by The Paris ReviewAt Home among the Birds: An Interview with Jonathan Meiburg by John Jeremiah SullivanEvery Poem Has Ancestors by Joy HarjoStaff Picks: Cornets, Collections, and Corn Tempura by The Paris ReviewPoets on Couches: John Murillo and Nicole Sealey Read Anne Waldman by John Murillo and Nicole SealeyThe Things We Hide: An Interview with Megan Abbott by Rebecca GodfreyProcrastination, Pressure, and Poetry: An Interview with Kendra Allen by Lauren KaneThe Winners of 92Y’s 2021 Discovery Poetry Contest by The Paris ReviewPicture Books as Doors to Other Worlds by Elissa Washuta Mindfulness meditation and selfies have a weird connection Video games and mindfulness have a surprising history Staff Picks: Bardi, Baseball, and LSD Best Black Friday AirPods deals: AirPods Pro at new record Joy Williams Will Receive Our 2018 Hadada Award Black Friday 2023: Everything you need to know Illicit Love Letters: Albert Camus and Maria Casares How to watch CU vs. Utah football without cable: Kickoff time, streaming deals, and more News as Art in 2018 Not a Nice Girl: On the Life and Photography of Berenice Abbott Schlemihls and Water Sprites The Moment of the Applause by Amit Chaudhuri Best Black Friday Apple AirTags deals in 2023 How to post on Instagram for just Close Friends Ode to Joy Staff Picks: Kendrick, Cardi Covers, and Cautionary Tales On Telling Ugly Stories: Writing with a Chronic Illness Seven and a Half Short Notes on Sandy Denny Best deals of the day March 29: SolaWave skincare wand, Shark self Black Friday Apple Watch deals: Get an SE for $179
2.7093s , 10193.9765625 kb
Copyright © 2025 Powered by 【pornogrpahic eroticism definition】,Exquisite Information Network