Launching a Tesla Roadster into outer space may have Secret Tutoring (2018)been ridiculous, but the vehicle is far from being worthless space junk.
The stunt actually served an important engineering purpose.
Engineers commonly load their rockets with heavy simulation cargo -- often made of metal -- so they can accurately test how these expensive launchers will behave as they blast through the skies at some 18,000 miles per hour.
SEE ALSO: Elon Musk's outer space Tesla will overshoot Mars and land somewhere in the asteroid beltElon Musk -- in a somewhat grotesque show of wealth -- decided to send a Tesla in lieu of hunks of metal, called mass models, which are intended to simulate how a load of cargo will act during a rocket's flight.
Scientists: "Space junk is a major problem. The amount of debris in space will triple by 2030. It can destroy satellites and is lethal to people going on future space missions."
— Jared Wall (@JaredWall01) February 7, 2018
Elon Musk: "Word. Hey, watch me shoot this car into space."
"They’re dummy versions of actual satellites," Jonathan McDowell, an astronomer at the Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics, said in an interview.
Although Musk sensationalized his cargo simulation, these space-bound loads can also be pretty mundane.
"They're historically made to be simple, easy, boring, and cheap simulations," said Tommy Sanford, director of the Commercial Spaceflight Federation, in an interview.
"They use something like heavy cinder blocks -- it puts the 'dumb' in dummy payload," said Sanford.
These dummy simulations serve two necessary functions.
First, most SpaceX customers, like the U.S government, pay the spaceflight company to launch extremely expensive (in the hundreds of millions of dollars) satellites into space. Accordingly, SpaceX needs to tell satellite-makers how much their gear will bounce around and vibrate during the launch, so the pricy machines are prepared for the intense experience.
"Most of the interesting data comes in the first few minutes, because that's where the ride is pretty rough," said McDowell. "So you can see the experience that your satellite is going to have."
"It's just to prove to future customers that their payload is comfortable," noted Sanford.
Second, rocket companies like SpaceX want to know how the cargo they're blasting into space will affect the rocket.
Cargo is positioned atop the rocket in an area called the "payload fairing." As this stuff vibrates, it can affect the rocket -- and engineers don't want excessive jolting to occur during an already precarious, high-speed operation.
"It's possible for the satellite to feed back into the fairing," said McDowell, who noted that past fairing failures have occurred for this very reason.
Rocket scientists, however, usually have a pretty good idea going into a launch of how their rocket will behave. The launch is often just a confirmation that the rocket works -- and can handle heavy loads.
"The launch is to prove out that ground simulations and computer modeling are correct -- or at least mostly correct," said Sanford.
SpaceX engineers were mostly correct in their launch calculations, which included the weight of the Roadster and the domed-base it sat on. But if SpaceX could allocate resources to attach the Roadster to a platform, surround it with sturdy cameras, and fit the "Starman" mannequin into a spacesuit, it seems likely that could have -- at minimum -- incorporated some scientific value into this simulated cargo-turned-space debris.
With a bit of foresight, the Roadster -- or a far cheaper object -- likely could have been fitted with some data or image-collecting technology that could have been of use to astronomers. After all, any data gathered in space is valuable.
FAQ
— Mika McKinnon (@mikamckinnon) February 8, 2018
Q: Is firing a Tesla into space legal?
A: Yes
Q: Is it just going to keep orbiting forever?
A: Pretty much, yes
Q: Could the car have served a scientific purpose if outfitted differently?
A: Yes
Q: What prevents other billionaires from doing similar launches?
A: Nothing
During a press briefing following the successful launch of the Falcon Heavy, however, Musk said that SpaceX isn't necessarily planning to track the car through its solar system orbit, leaving astronomers to investigate where the Tesla might go.
Elon is still talking about the Starman going to the asteroid belt. But I'm not convinced yet... https://t.co/yoU5fCPHKb
— Jonathan McDowell (@planet4589) February 7, 2018
Then there's the growing problem of space debris. It's typical for any test launch to leave debris in the Earth's orbit.
Rocket launches of all persuasions can create space junk unless they're designed to be brought back down to Earth and crash into the ocean. Or, in SpaceX's case, land on drone ships and be reused.
But when rockets leave this test cargo in space -- like a pile of cinderblocks -- this space debris isn't just haphazardly left to wander around its orbit.
"People could always argue about debris and define it as debris, but when they do those early launches with dummy payload, they make sure they put the dummy payload into a graveyard or inoperable orbit that is not of value to the space community and something that won’t be a threat to future activities in space," said Sanford.
For those concerned about the Tesla Roadster adding to the problem of space litter orbiting Earth, in this case the test cargo has rocketed into deeper space -- far away from Earth's orbit -- meaning that the usual concerns about space debris crowding out Earth's part of space are somewhat unfounded.
The Roadster will orbit the sun, not the Earth, and thus won't add to the thousands of pieces of junk orbiting our planet, such as derelict satellites and tiny screws.
"That doesn’t mean I think it's fine to arbitrarily launch junk out there [into space]," said McDowell. "But it's not a problem in the way that Earth orbital debris is."
There are still valid concerns that human-made objects could impact icy moons around Jupiter and Saturn, possibly disturbing any life that may exist there or even seeding it with our own life. That said, the possibility of that kind of impact is incredibly low.
The cherry red Roadster has already passed the moon, and McDowell estimates that the vehicle will hit its farthest away point from the sun -- somewhere past Mars -- in November 2018.
How to practice gratitude in 2021How performative became the most searing callout in 2020How to use Netflix's New Year's Day recommendations hotline5 indie gems in 2020 that you might've missed (but should check out)Dog and kitten are the epitome of friendship goalsThis cuddly little guy washed up on a beach in Texas and it's literally the absolute cutestThis woman's pet pug needed a tuxedo, so she used public money to pay for it'Wonder Woman 1984' has a musical connection to 'Batman v Superman'Watch Baby Yoda bop to a tune from director Robert RodriguezReverse cat eyeliner is the weird makeup trend du jour. Make it stop.An elderly man's words about his late wife reduced a shop full of people to tearsMyLife review: The mindfulness app that hooks meditation skepticsBad news for free speech: An ESPN anchor criticized Trump and now the White House wants her firedPhish challenges fans to an online chess game on New Year's Eve 2020When a terrified biker crosses paths with an unexpected bear no one winsMyLife review: The mindfulness app that hooks meditation skepticsLove your pet? Why not get their face printed on a swimsuitAnother council is stopping its Australia Day celebrationsThese makeup kits look just like '90s Polly Pocket casesTwitter is downright horny for 'Bridgerton' memes Staff Picks: Diamonds, Dionysus, and Drowning by The Paris Review German Lessons by Margaret Drabble They Think They Know You, Lionel Messi by Rowan Ricardo Phillips Staff Picks: Sex, Stand Behind the Scenes of ‘The Paris Review Podcast’ by The Paris Review Breaking the Rules: An Interview with the Astro Poets by Julia Berick One Word: Salty by Myriam Gurba Sum Effects by Peggy Shinner Robert Lowell Dressed as Santa by Saskia Hamilton Detroit Archives: On Haunting by Aisha Sabatini Sloan A Figure Model’s (Brief) Guide to Poses through Art History by Larissa Pham Listen to Hebe Uhart, Now That She’s Gone by Alejandra Costamagna God’s Wife: An Interview with Amanda Michalopoulou by Christopher Merrill On Desolation: Vija Celmins’s Gray by John Vincler Comics as System by Ivan Brunetti The Controversial Origin of Asian American Studies by Tara Fickle The Whole Fucking Paradigm by Andre Perry Reimagining Masculinity by Ocean Vuong We Lived Here by Jill Talbot The Village Explainer by Anthony Madrid
2.3449s , 10159.03125 kb
Copyright © 2025 Powered by 【Secret Tutoring (2018)】,Exquisite Information Network