【Privacy policy】

NeoGAF,Privacy policy one of the lingering examples of what gaming fandom on the internet looked like in an era before social media, is going through some shit.

Stop me if you've heard this one before: The owner of a long-lived, community-driven website is the subject of sexual harassment allegations. Such revelations have surfaced before, but in this post-Weinstein period when names are being named, the new information has triggered a mass exodus among the site's users and staff.

SEE ALSO: James Toback is the latest filmmaker to be outed as a sexual predator

It started last week when the site's owner, Tyler Malka, was publicly accused of sexual harassment. In the hours and days that followed, a number of the gaming forum's moderators publicly stepped down and a growing number of users -- some of them longtime fixtures on the site -- declared that they were done.

It was a similar situation back in September for another example of Old Internet: Movie news and rumormill site Ain't It Cool News. Sexual harassment charges swirled around Harry Knowles, the site's founder. He initially pushed back, but ultimately stepped down as more stories floated to the surface.

Original image has been replaced. Credit: Mashable

For Malka and NeoGAF, it started with a Facebook post last week. In her own contribution to the #MeToo hashtag, filmmaker Ima Leupp described an ugly experience she'd had in 2015 with an unnamed assailant. It wasn't until later, in a comment on the same post, that she named him, indirectly: "Google Evilore," Leupp wrote.

Mashable Top Stories Stay connected with the hottest stories of the day and the latest entertainment news. Sign up for Mashable's Top Stories newsletter By clicking Sign Me Up, you confirm you are 16+ and agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Thanks for signing up!

Evilore is Malka's NeoGAF username. The gaming forum he presides over hasn't ever been the gentlest place. Anytime you hear talk about "console wars" or "resolutiongate" or other trifling, in-the-weeds gaming "controversies," there's probably a 100-page long discussion thread about it on NeoGAF.

Politically, however, the site has embraced a firmer stance in recent years. A distinctly progressive mindset has become the norm there, fostered by the NeoGAF's team of moderators. Over time it's been made clear that toxic viewpoints, such as those embraced by the Gamergate hate group, are not welcome on GAF.

Much like Knowles, Malka has positioned himself publicly as a defender of progressive values. Though, as NeoGAF users tell it, that attitude seems to stop short of issues relating to sexual misconduct.

Kotaku's report on the NeoGAF situation cites users who have taken note of Malka's more problematic, occasionally tyrannical behavior. One claimed to have been banned for making the case that Playboy's Hugh Hefner wasn't a feminist icon. Another claims they were shut down for supporting the #BelieveWomen hashtag.

This paragraph is particularly telling:

In one thread, a NeoGAF poster uploaded screencaps of another woman’s #MeToo post, involving allegations about a film journalist. Malka asked, “No evidence at all? No corroborating testimony? No behavioral red flags?,” adding, “So far this is nothing like other recent industry scandals.” Later, after receiving pushback from posters who found his initial comment callous, Malka described posters’ immediate support of the #MeToo post as “witch hunts,” adding that it will take time for the allegations’ veracity to be proven. Several vocal critics of Malka’s approach say they were banned. One of Malka’s posts responding to a ban read, “Fuck off, dipshit. That enough toxic masculinity for you? I was moderating my platform, not going to bat for Dr. Neckbeard.”

I highly recommend reading the rest of that report. It's one of the most thorough investigative looks out there right now at what's happened with NeoGAF, as well as the history that brought the site to this point.

This is far from over. NeoGAF is still down for "scheduled maintenance" (LOL) as of Monday morning. The picture of what's ahead for the gaming forum should become clearer once it's back online, and once Malka has responded -- in a statement that is also still believed to be forthcoming.

---

Featured Video For You

---

Jennifer Lawrence, Reese Witherspoon speak out about sexual harassment in Hollywood

---

Topics Gaming